The CBA Glossary
An explainer thing for the NBA's Collective Bargaining Agreement
Player Conduct Matters
Yeah.
Threshold Tax calculations Tax Rates Repeater tax Rebates
The Luxury Tax Threshold
Player ownership of teams
As a general rule, no active NBA
player is allowed to own, directly or indirectly, any part of an NBA team
or any company that owns an NBA team. The only exception is that a player
may own less than 1% of a publicly traded company that happens to own an NBA
franchise (a reduction from 5% in the previous CBA). ⓘArticle
XXIX (Miscellareous) Section 12 (Limitation on Player Ownership):
(a) During the term of this Agreement, no NBA player may acquire or hold a
direct or indirect interest in the ownership of any NBA Team or in any company
or entity, whether privately or publicly owned, that owns any interest in
any NBA Team; provided, however, that any player may have an ownership of
publicly-traded securities constituting less than one percent (1%) of the
ownership interests in a company or entity that directly or indirectly owns
an NBA Team.
However, the Players Association,
acting on behalf of all NBA players, is allowed to invest in NBA teams through
certain NBA-approved private investment funds. These investments must be passive,
meaning the NBPA cannot influence how the teams are run, vote on team matters,
or take part in management decisions. The NBPA's investment also cannot exceed
5% of the total capital committed to any such fund. ⓘArticle
XXIX (Miscellareous) Section 12 (Limitation on Player Ownership):
(b) Notwithstanding Section 12(a) above, and subject to Sections 12(c) and
12(d) below, during the term of this Agreement, the Players Association or
an affiliate of the Players Association may invest on behalf of all NBA players
in one or more private investment funds approved by the NBA to acquire passive,
non-voting minority interests in one or more NBA Teams in accordance with
all applicable NBA rules and regulations (each, a “Private Investment Fund”);
provided, however, that any such investments shall be subject to the following
conditions and limitations:
(i) Any such investment must be passive and non-voting and may not, at any
time, exceed five percent (5%) of the aggregate committed capital of such
Private Investment Fund [...]
The NBPA must follow the same general
rules that apply to other investors in these funds, such as meeting legal
requirements for investors and minimum investment levels. In addition, the
NBPA is prohibited from receiving special access, privileged information,
advisory positions, committee memberships or any other role that would give
it greater influence than a normal passive investor. If any of these requirements
stop being satisfied, the NBPA must reduce or sell its investment. ⓘArticle
XXIX (Miscellareous) Section 12 (Limitation on Player Ownership):
[...] (ii) The Players Association shall be subject to the same general restrictions
and rules as applicable to other investors in such Private Investment Fund
(e.g., compliance with applicable “accredited investor” requirements and
minimum investment thresholds);
(iii) Notwithstanding subparagraph (ii) above, the Players Association shall
be prohibited from holding or exercising any active participation rights or
roles, and from receiving any enhanced information, with respect to a Private
Investment Fund, including serving on limited partner or other advisory committees
of a Private Investment Fund; and
(iv) The Players Association shall be required to divest or reduce its ownership
interest in a Private Investment Fund if any of the conditions set forth in
subparagraphs (i)-(iii) above cease to be met.
Any investment made under these
rules must comply with all applicable laws, including securities regulations
and federal labour laws. If a legal problem arises, then as with most things
in the CBA, the parties must first try to modify either the investment arrangement
or the CBA language so that it becomes compliant. If that cannot be done,
the investment must be fully sold off and the offending portions of the rule
become void. ⓘArticle XXIX (Miscellareous)
Section 12 (Limitation on Player Ownership):
(c) Any Players Association investment in one or more Private Investment Funds
shall be subject to compliance with all applicable laws, including but not
limited to securities laws and federal labor law. If, at any point, any Players
Association investment or provision of this Section 12 does not comply with
applicable laws, then the Players Association shall use best efforts to, and
cause the Private Investment Fund to, modify the terms of such investment
and/or the parties will negotiate in good faith to modify the terms of this
Section 12, in each case, to the extent necessary to fully comply with law
and, if such modifications are not or cannot be negotiated, then (i) the applicable
Players Association investment shall be divested in full and (ii) the applicable
terms of this Section 12 shall be rendered void and of no further force and
effect.
A joint NBA-NBPA Investment Committee
exists to study these issues and explore whether broader forms of investment
might be possible in the future. Potential topics include allowing players
to invest collectively through a pooled investment vehicle or allowing players
to invest in businesses affiliated with NBA teams. Before any such arrangements
can be approved, both the NBA and NBPA must obtain legal advice confirming
that the investments comply with labour laws. No new investment structure
can be implemented until both sides are satisfied that it is legal and agree
on any necessary rules governing it. The Investment Committee consists of
three representatives chosen by the NBA and three chosen by the NBPA. At least
one representative from each side must have expertise in private investment
funds. Unless the NBA and NBPA agree otherwise, committee members cannot themselves
have a financial stake in any of the private investment funds being discussed.
The committee may also hire outside legal or investment experts, with the
NBA and NBPA sharing those costs equally. ⓘArticle
XXIX (Miscellareous) Section 12 (Limitation on Player Ownership):
(d) Immediately following the execution of this Agreement, the NBA and the
Players Association shall form a joint advisory committee (the “Investment
Committee”) to study and discuss in good faith any issues relating to (x)
the Players Association’s or an affiliate of the Players Association’s
investment in Private Investment Funds in accordance with Sections 12(b) and
12(c) above, as well as (y) a potential CBA modification pertaining to (i)
investment in Private Investment Funds by individual players investing collectively
through a pooled investment vehicle (a “Players Vehicle”), and/or (ii)
investment by individual players in NBA affiliated businesses, in each case
taking into account all appropriate legal, business, and other considerations.
Prior to any such investment, the members of the Investment Committee, either
jointly or independently through each respective party, shall obtain the advice
of counsel to the satisfaction of both the NBA and the Players Association
stating that such investment complies with applicable labor laws, including,
without limitation, Section 302 of the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947 (Labor Management
Relations Act of 1947). For clarity, (1) no investment contemplated under
this Section 12(d) shall be permitted unless and until such time as the NBA
and the Players Association confirm to their satisfaction that such investment
would comply with all applicable laws, and (2) no investment by a Players
Vehicle in a Private Investment Fund or investment by players in NBA affiliated
businesses shall be permitted unless and until such time as the NBA and the
Players Association agree upon any new structures and/or rules required for
such investment.
(i) The Investment Committee shall consist of three (3) representatives appointed
by the NBA and three (3) representatives appointed by the Players Association.
At least one of the members appointed by each of the NBA and the Players Association
must be knowledgeable of private investment funds and their structures. Unless
otherwise mutually agreed by the parties, Investment Committee members may
not have an ownership or other financial interest in any Private Investment
Fund.
(ii) The Investment Committee may jointly retain such experts as it deems
necessary in order to conduct its work, which the parties expect to include
investment and legal professionals. The costs of such experts will be borne
equally by the NBA and the Players Association.
● ----
There is a bit more leeway when it comes to NBA player ownership of WNBA teams.
An NBA player may invest in a WNBA
team only if that team is completely independent of NBA ownership.
Some are, but some aren't. In other words, it must be a team in which no NBA
team owner, nor any member of an NBA team owner's family, has a direct or
indirect ownership stake in the WNBA franchise. The investment must also be
approved by the WNBA and must generally be made on the same terms available
to other outside investors. A player's ownership stake in an eligible WNBA
team cannot exceed 4% of the team. Collectively, all NBA players together
cannot own more than 8% of the same WNBA franchise, and an individual player
can only own a stake in one WNBA team at a time. ⓘArticle
XXIX (Miscellareous) Section 13 (Player Ownership in Independent WNBA Teams):
(a) Subject to Section 13(b) below and also subject to WNBA approval in each
case, and notwithstanding anything to the contrary in Article XIII, Section
2(c), an NBA player may invest in a WNBA Team in which no Team Owner (or family
member of a Team Owner) has a direct or indirect beneficial ownership interest
(each such team, an “Independent WNBA Team”) on substantially similar
terms to other third-party investors, subject to the following conditions
and limitations:
(i) An NBA player’s ownership interest in an Independent WNBA Team may not,
at any time, exceed four percent (4%) of such Independent WNBA Team;
(ii) NBA players may not in the aggregate hold more than an eight percent
(8%) ownership interest in any Independent WNBA Team;
(iii) An NBA player may hold an ownership interest in only one (1) Independent
WNBA Team at any one time;
(iv) Any NBA player investing in an Independent WNBA Team shall be subject
to WNBA restrictions, rules, and penalties, as imposed and enforced by the
WNBA, applicable to other WNBA team owners (e.g., relating to tampering, public
comments on collectively bargained matters, and penalties for misconduct)
These restrictions apply not only
to the player personally but also to any company, trust, relative or other
entity acting on the player's behalf or under the player's control. Additionally,
player agents and representatives are expressly prohibited from investing
in WNBA teams. ⓘArticle XXIX
(Miscellareous) Section 13 (Player Ownership in Independent WNBA Teams):
(c) For purposes of this Section 13, a “player” shall include any person
or entity controlled by, related to, or acting with authority on behalf of
a player. For clarity, and notwithstanding anything to contrary in this Section
13, no agent or representative of a player may invest in a WNBA team.
Any player who becomes an owner
must follow the same basic rules that apply to other WNBA owners, including
rules regarding tampering,
public comments on labour matters and standards of conduct. However, players
are specifically prohibited from having any governance role in either the
WNBA team or the league itself. They cannot sit on boards, committees, governing
bodies or otherwise participate in running the team or league. To further
reduce potential conflicts, players are only entitled to receive very limited
information about the team - their access is restricted to annual audited
financial statements and any tax information they are legally required to
receive. They are not entitled to broader business, competitive or strategic
information. If any of these conditions stop being satisfied, the NBA can
require the player to reduce or completely sell their ownership stake. ⓘArticle
XXIX (Miscellareous) Section 13 (Player Ownership in Independent WNBA Teams):
(v) Notwithstanding subparagraph (iv) above, an NBA player shall be prohibited
from holding any governance rights or roles with respect to an Independent
WNBA Team in which he holds an ownership interest or with respect to the WNBA,
including participation on WNBA team or WNBA league governing bodies;
(vii) An NBA player may be required by the NBA to divest or reduce his ownership
interest in an Independent WNBA Team if any of the conditions set forth in
subparagraphs (i)-(vi) above cease to be met [...]
[...] (b) NBA player investment in Independent WNBA Teams shall be subject
to compliance with all applicable laws, including but not limited to securities
laws and federal labor law. If, at any point, any player investment or provision
of this Section 13 does not comply with applicable laws, then the player shall
use best efforts to, and cause the Independent WNBA Team to, modify the terms
of such investment and/or the parties will negotiate in good faith to modify
the terms of this Section 13, in each case, to the extent necessary to fully
comply with law and, if such modifications are not or cannot be negotiated,
then (i) the applicable player investment shall be divested in full and (ii)
the applicable terms of this Section 13 shall be rendered void and of no further
force and effect.
The agreement also addresses what
happens if the WNBA team later becomes connected to NBA ownership. If the
WNBA franchise proposes to sell a controlling interest to an NBA owner or
a member of an NBA owner's family, any NBA player who owns part of the team
must completely dispose of their investment. The team's governing documents
must contain the necessary "tag-along" and "drag-along"
provisions to ensure that players can be required to sell when such a transaction
occurs. Even if the proposed sale is for less than a controlling interest,
the player still cannot remain invested if the result would be an NBA owner
acquiring an ownership stake. The player must first sell their entire interest
to someone who is not an NBA owner or a family member of one. ⓘArticle
XXIX (Miscellareous) Section 13 (Player Ownership in Independent WNBA Teams):
(viii) In the event an Independent WNBA Team in which an NBA player is invested
proposes to sell a “controlling ownership interest” to a Team Owner (or
family member of a Team Owner), any NBA player investor in such Independent
WNBA Team will be required to dispose of its entire ownership interest in
such Independent WNBA Team, including through the exercise of any tag-along
or drag-along rights applicable to such ownership interest. For purposes of
this Section 13, a “controlling ownership interest” means a majority of
the voting or equity interests in, or contractual control of, the Independent
WNBA Team. If the Independent WNBA Team’s existing governing agreements
do not contain provisions with such rights, then such agreements shall be
amended in connection with an NBA player’s investment to create customary
tag-along or drag-along rights with respect to the player’s interests, and
such amendment shall be a condition to such NBA player’s investment. For
clarity, in the event an Independent WNBA Team in which an NBA player is invested
proposes to sell less than a controlling ownership interest to a Team Owner
(or a family member of a Team Owner), such proposed transaction will not be
in compliance with Section 13(a)(1) above unless such NBA player disposes
of his entire ownership interest in such Independent WNBA Team by selling
to a person or entity that is not a Team Owner (or a family member of a Team
Owner), prior to such proposed sale.
(Must comply with all security
and labour law, yada yada yada, as above.) ⓘArticle
XXIX (Miscellareous) Section 13 (Player Ownership in Independent WNBA Teams):
(ii) The Investment Committee may jointly retain such experts as it deems
necessary in order to conduct its work, which the parties expect to include
investment and legal professionals. The costs of such experts will be borne
equally by the NBA and the Players Association.
Team rules
Each team is allowed to establish
rules that players must follow both on and off the court, as long as they
are in writing, reasonable, and not in conflict with the CBA or the UPC. This
includes stuff like dress codes, curfews and attendance at team events. ⓘ
Article XXVI: (Team Rules), Section
1. (Establishment of Team Rules):
Each Team may maintain or establish rules with which its players shall comply
at all times, whether on or off the playing floor; provided, however, that
such rules are in writing, are reasonable, and do not violate the provisions
of this Agreement or the Uniform Player Contract.
Before a team distributes a new
rule to its players, it must first provide a copy of the rule to the Players
Association. If the Players Association believes a team rule is unreasonable,
it may file a grievance within within 30 days after the player became aware,
or reasonably should have become aware, of the rule/its violation. Any ruling
in the player's favour rewards that player only - other players cannot
automatically go back and undo prior discipline based on that same ruling.
ⓘ Article XXVI: (Team Rules),
Section 2. (Notice):
Any rule(s) established by a Team pursuant to Section 1 above shall be provided
to the Players Association prior to the distribution of such rule(s) to that
Team’s players.
Article XXVI: (Team Rules), Section 3. (Grievances Challening Team Rules):
The Players Association may file a Grievance challenging the reasonableness
of a rule established by a Team pursuant to Section 1 above, and the Team’s
imposition of discipline on a player for a violation of such rule, within
thirty (30) days from the date upon which the imposition of such discipline
on the player became known or reasonably should have become known to the player.
No ruling by the Grievance Arbitrator finding a Team rule unreasonable may
be applied retroactively as to any player other than the player on whose behalf
the Grievance was filed.
Tax rebates
Threshold Tax calculations Tax Rates Repeater tax Rebates
MAIN TAKEAWAYS:
- The more your team are over the luxury tax threshold, the more your team will pay.
- The more regularly your team is over the luxury tax threshold, the more your team will pay, too.
- Teams under the tax threshold not only avoid penalty, but get rebates, which do not change their salary cap picture but which do improve the cash position.
- In addition to the luxury tax - whose effectiveness as a payroll deterrent had dwindled in light of the Golden State Warriors' extravagant spending - the NBA has recently introduced the "apron" thresholds, which exist in addition to the tax, and which are designed to reduce excessive spending not just through extra payments but through reduced spending options. See the Aprons page for more.